A Comprehensive Overview by Claude
Open-Glottis Breathing
A Plain-English Guide — With Fact Check
by CEJames (arthor) & Akira Ichinose (editor/research assistant)
What it is, why it matters, and what the research actually says
1. First: What Is the Glottis?
Think of your throat like a hallway with a swinging door in the middle. That door is the glottis — a small gap between your vocal cords, sitting right in the middle of your voice box (larynx).
In everyday life, this door is almost always open. Every time you breathe in or out, air flows freely through it. Your vocal cords sit in a relaxed "V" shape, out of the way.
The glottis closes in two situations:
• When you swallow (to stop food going down your windpipe)
• When you hold your breath on purpose — to strain, grunt, or brace
Open-glottis breathing simply means keeping that door open — letting air flow in or out — even while you're doing something effortful.
In a nutshell:
Open glottis = air is moving. Closed glottis = breath is held. That's the whole distinction.
2. The Opposite: Holding Your Breath (Closed-Glottis / Valsalva)
When you hold your breath and strain — think of lifting something really heavy, or how you might brace before a big effort — you're doing what scientists call the Valsalva maneuver. Your glottis snaps shut, trapping air inside your lungs.
This does something useful: it stiffens your whole torso like an inflated balloon, which helps protect your spine under heavy loads. That's why powerlifters hold their breath during a max squat.
But it also comes with trade-offs:
• Blood pressure spikes sharply
• Heart rate swings up and then dips
• Pressure surges in your belly — pushing down on your pelvic floor
• Oxygen delivery to your muscles temporarily dips
For brief, extreme efforts, this is fine and even helpful. But doing it all day — during regular workouts, everyday lifting, or for hours during childbirth — is where it causes problems.
3. How Open-Glottis Breathing Works in the Body
When your glottis stays open and you breathe while doing something effortful, a few things happen differently:
Belly Pressure Stays Manageable
Your belly is like a sealed cylinder — squeeze the top (diaphragm), the bottom (pelvic floor), or the sides (abdominal muscles), and pressure rises inside. When you hold your breath, that pressure gets "locked in" and can't escape. Open-glottis breathing lets it vent gradually through your airway, so the pressure stays more controlled.
This matters especially if you have pelvic floor issues, are pregnant, or are recovering from abdominal surgery.
Your Balance Is Affected, Too
Here's a surprising finding from research: your glottis actually plays a small role in balance. A study in the Journal of Applied Physiology found that when people's glottis was completely open (like during a big sigh), their torso wobbled more when nudged. A partially engaged glottis — the way it naturally sits during normal activity — seems to lightly stiffen the trunk and help you stay upright.
The takeaway isn't "close your glottis all the time" — it's that the body naturally finds a middle ground, and deliberately forcing it fully open or shut disrupts that balance.
Blood and Oxygen Keep Flowing
Holding your breath hard enough compresses the big veins returning blood to your heart, briefly cutting cardiac output. Open-glottis breathing avoids this, keeping blood — and oxygen — flowing more steadily throughout your body and to any baby you might be pushing out.
4. Where You'll Encounter Open-Glottis Breathing
Exercise and Weightlifting
You've probably heard "exhale on the effort" in a fitness class. That's open-glottis coaching. For most gym exercises, breathing through the movement is safer and builds more sustainable strength than holding your breath.
Holding your breath for a hard deadlift or squat max is different — that's a calculated, brief technique used by experienced lifters. But if you find yourself naturally holding your breath to open a jar or carry groceries, that's a sign your core stability could use some work.
5. How to Practice Open-Glottis Breathing
The good news: your body already knows how to do this. You do it every moment of every day that you're not actively holding your breath. Practicing is mostly about learning NOT to close your glottis reflexively during effort.
The Toilet Practice (Really!)
Here's a surprisingly useful exercise: next time you have a bowel movement, practice exhaling slowly while you bear down instead of holding your breath. It feels counterintuitive at first, but many physiotherapists recommend this exact method to train open-glottis.
The Fog-a-Mirror Exhale
Open your mouth in a relaxed "O" shape and breathe out as if you're trying to fog up a cold mirror — slow, steady, not forced. That open-throat sensation is what you're aiming for during effort.
The Groan or Hum
During heavy lifting or exertion, making a low sound — a hum, a groan, an "shhh" — keeps your glottis open and air moving. Elite athletes and martial artists do this naturally (that's what the tennis grunt is). It's not just drama; it's physiology.
6. Fact-Check: Sorting the Solid from the Shaky
Here's an honest look at the major claims made about open-glottis breathing, separated into what's well-proven and what's being over-sold.
Sources
The following sources informed this document. All are peer-reviewed, authoritative clinical sources, or major medical reference bodies.
1. Barasinski, C. et al. (2020). EOLE Study — open vs closed glottis pushing in labor. Midwifery, 91, 102843.
2. Talasz, H. et al. (2012). Proof of concept: Valsalva vs straining maneuver effects on pelvic floor. European Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology, 164(2), 227–233.
3. NICE Evidence Review. (2023). Pushing techniques in labor. NCBI Bookshelf NBK596203.
4. Tsai, T.C. & Hodges, P.W. (2013). Effect of airway control by glottal structures on postural stability. Journal of Applied Physiology, 115(4), 582–592.
5. Herrera-Cortina et al. (2016). ELTGOL vs other airway clearance techniques. Referenced in Bronchiectasis.com.au.
6. Desjardins, M. & Bonilha, H.S. (2019). Respiratory exercises and voice outcomes: systematic review. Journal of Voice, 34(4), 648.e1–648.e39.
7. Talasz, H. et al. (2022). Breathing, (s)training and the pelvic floor. PMC9222935.
8. StatPearls: Valsalva Maneuver. NCBI Bookshelf NBK537248.
9. StatPearls: Anatomy of the Larynx and Cricoarytenoid. NCBI Bookshelf NBK538307.
10. Cleveland Clinic: Glottis anatomy and function. my.clevelandclinic.org/health/body/glottis.
11. Kenhub: Glottis anatomy, structure and function. kenhub.com.
12. CF Physio: Forced Expiratory Technique and Huffing. cfphysio.com.
13. Salomoni, S. et al. (2016). Breathing and singing: objective characterization of breathing patterns in classical singers. PLOS ONE, 11, e0155084.
14. Wallace, K. (2020). Valsalva and the Vaginal Vacuum. kathewallace.com.
15. SingWise: Breath management and support of the singing voice. singwise.com.
______________________
1. Anatomy of the Glottis
To understand open-glottis breathing, one must first understand the relevant anatomy. The glottis consists of the vocal folds and the opening between them, called the rima glottidis. It is located in the middle part of the laryngeal cavity, between the supraglottis and subglottis. Your vocal cords usually rest in an open position like a “V” in your glottis. When you inhale, air from your nose and/or mouth passes between your open vocal cords on the way to your windpipe and then your lungs. Your vocal cords are also open as you breathe out.
During regular breathing at rest, the rima glottidis is a narrow wedge shape, but during forced respiration it is a wide triangular shape and the vocal cords are as far apart as they can extend. This aperture in men is approximately 2 to 2.4 cm in length, and the width ranges from 0.5 cm during ordinary breathing to 1.4 cm during deep breathing.
The posterior cricoarytenoid muscle is the only abductor of the true vocal cords, opening the rima glottidis via lateral rotation of the arytenoids, maximizing the passage of air during inspiration and expiration. Primarily the lateral cricoarytenoid muscles, but also the interarytenoid and thyroarytenoid muscles, provide the opposing action, closing the rima glottidis via adduction of the true vocal cords.
2. What “Open-Glottis Breathing” Means
Open-glottis breathing simply means that airflow continues uninterrupted — the vocal cords are not pressed together to hold back air. Quiet breathing occurs largely independent of conscious perception by means of continuous phase-locked activity of the autonomously innervated deep trunk muscles with an always-open glottis to allow airflow into and out of the lungs. In contrast, its opposite — the closed-glottis or Valsalva maneuver — involves forceful exhalation against a closed glottis, producing significant hemodynamic changes.
During exhalation, the vocal cords can either remain open for normal breathing or close to allow pressure build-up for actions like coughing or lifting heavy objects. The key distinction of open-glottis breathing is that the exhalation (or any effortful action) is performed while air is flowing, not while it is held.
3. Physiology: Intra-Abdominal Pressure and Spinal Stability
One of the most clinically significant aspects of open-glottis breathing concerns its effect on intra-abdominal pressure (IAP) and trunk stability. The respiratory muscles, including the respiratory diaphragm and the intercostals, pelvic diaphragm and the glottis, contribute to postural stability by regulating intrathoracic pressure (ITP) and IAP.
Open-glottis breathing will generally create less intra-abdominal pressure (IAP). Higher IAP can be either good or bad, depending on intention. High IAP is often used intentionally during heavy weightlifting to stabilize the core and spine, enhancing the lifter’s ability to handle heavier loads. While effective for stabilization, high IAP also significantly increases blood pressure and can pose risks, especially for individuals with cardiovascular issues, or pelvic floor vulnerability.
Research published in the Journal of Applied Physiology found that when the glottis was completely open during a sigh, thoracic displacement in response to a perturbation was greater than in all other conditions, regardless of direction of perturbation, suggesting that glottal control influences balance. In other words, a fully open glottis during movement reduces trunk stability relative to partially engaged glottal control.
For most fitness activities, breathing should be open-glottis, rhythmic, and match the movement. If a person needs closed-glottis stability just for daily activities or “normal” strength training, it is a sign of poor function and low core stability — open-glottis breathing raises the bar for what the body can functionally handle.
4. Open-Glottis Breathing in Childbirth
The most clinically studied context for open-glottis breathing is labor and delivery, where it is contrasted with closed-glottis (Valsalva) pushing.
Open-glottis pushing involves exhaling while pushing during contractions. The woman takes a deep breath and then exhales slowly and steadily while pushing, allowing the glottis to remain open. This approach mimics the natural urge to bear down that many women feel during the later stages of labor. It is also called spontaneous pushing or breathing down.
Open-glottis pushing is beneficial because it decreases the baby’s risk of heart rate changes (by allowing uninterrupted blood flow to the uterus and baby) and helps avoid fatigue. Closed-glottis pushing can restrict blood flow to the uterus and baby and puts forceful pressure on the baby, umbilical cord, and tissues.
The research evidence is nuanced. A major NICE evidence review (covering studies from Brazil, Canada, Denmark, France, Hong Kong, Iran, Ireland, Spain, Turkey, the United Kingdom, and the United States) found that for multiparous women without an epidural, directed pushing with open glottis led to a reduction in the duration of the active second stage compared to directed pushing with a closed glottis. However, there was no evidence of an important difference between groups for nulliparous or mixed parity women, with or without an epidural, in terms of third/fourth degree tears.
One Egyptian study cited in the literature showed more dramatic benefits: one study found that open-glottis users had babies with better 5-minute Apgar scores and better umbilical artery pH, with oxygen not needed at all in the open-glottis group compared to 74% in the closed-glottis group. However, as noted in the fact-check below, this single study should not be overgeneralized.
5. ELTGOL: Open-Glottis Breathing for Airway Clearance
A specialized clinical application of open-glottis breathing is the technique called ELTGOL — Expiration with an Open Glottis in the Lateral posture — used in pulmonary physiotherapy, particularly for bronchiectasis.
In this technique, a patient adopts a lateral posture with the affected lung in the dependent position. The patient commences breathing normally at tidal volumes, then is instructed to perform a series of slow expirations with an open glottis. Expiration from functional residual capacity to the end of the expiratory reserve volume is encouraged to achieve maximum infralateral lung deflation. A mouthpiece may be used to decrease the degree of airway compression. When applied in the short term, ELTGOL has been found to be equally effective as other airway clearance techniques for overall sputum production over a 24-hour period.
6. Huffing (Forced Expiratory Technique)
A related open-glottis technique used in airway clearance is huffing: huffing involves taking a breath in followed by an active or forced expiration with the throat (glottis) open. This action creates a controlled squeezing of the airways and faster airflow that helps move mucus up the airway. To do a huff, one takes a breath in and breathes out fast enough with an open “O”-shaped mouth as if to fog up a mirror.
7. Open-Glottis Breathing in Singing and Voice
In voice training and classical singing, open-glottis breathing is essential for healthy phonation. Holding back the air either at the laryngeal level (where the singer closes the glottis immediately after inhalation and briefly pauses before producing voice) or at the supraglottic level (where throat muscles constrict and inhibit airflow) can cause subglottic pressure to rise, forcing the glottis to work harder and opening the door to potential injury.
In singing, the glottis plays a crucial role in producing sound, controlling pitch, and adding expressive qualities to the voice. When air passes through the glottis as the vocal cords vibrate, it generates sound. Singers learn to manipulate the tension and closure of the vocal cords to vary pitch and volume.
Research on professional singers shows that a study comparing singers’ performances with and without voluntarily engaging respiratory support revealed an increase in acoustic power and a decrease in expiratory airflow in the supported condition, indicating a more efficient phonation mode.
8. Pelvic Floor Health and Exercise
A schematic view of the abdominal cavity demonstrates the movements and contractile state of the muscle groups during physical strain with a “correct” contraction of the pelvic floor muscles and the anterolateral abdominal muscles during the exhaling of air through an open glottis. The continuously open glottis allows for air exhalation and prevents excessive intrathoracic pressure increases.
For people with pelvic floor dysfunction in particular, the distinction between Valsalva (closed-glottis breath hold) and strain maneuver matters clinically. The Valsalva maneuver reflects an expiratory pattern with diaphragm and pelvic floor elevation, whereas during straining the pelvic floor descends. This distinction has treatment implications for incontinence, prolapse, and pelvic rehabilitation.
Bibliography
1. Barasinski, C., Debost-Legrand, A., & Vendittelli, F. (2020). Is directed open-glottis pushing more effective than directed closed-glottis pushing during the second stage of labor? A pragmatic randomized trial – the EOLE study. Midwifery, 91, 102843. [PubMed: 32992159]
2. Baessler, K. et al. (2017). Valsalva versus straining: There is a distinct difference in resulting bladder neck and puborectalis muscle position. [PubMed: 28139845]
3. Desjardins, M., & Bonilha, H. S. (2019). The impact of respiratory exercises on voice outcomes: A systematic review of the literature. Journal of Voice, 34(4), 648.e1–648.e39.
4. Herrera-Cortina, et al. (2016). ELTGOL compared to other airway clearance techniques. Referenced in: Bronchiectasis.com.au. Retrieved from https://bronchiectasis.com.au/physiotherapy/techniques/expiration-with-an-open-glottis-in-the-lateral-posture
5. Kallet, R. H. (2011). Glossopharyngeal breathing. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. https://www.atsjournals.org/doi/full/10.1164/rccm.201012-2031IM
6. Massery, M. (2013). Using Voicing Strategies. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_VlBI-QgOw
7. NCBI Bookshelf / NICE Evidence Review. (2023). Evidence reviews for pushing techniques. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK596203/
8. Salomoni, S., van den Hoorn, W., & Hodges, P. (2016). Breathing and singing: Objective characterization of breathing patterns in classical singers. PLOS ONE, 11, e0155084.
9. Sapsford, R. R., & Hodges, P. W. (2001). Contraction of the pelvic floor muscles during abdominal maneuvers. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 82(8), 1081–1088.
10. StatPearls: Anatomy, Head and Neck: Cervical, Respiratory, Larynx, and Cricoarytenoid. NCBI Bookshelf. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK538307/
11. StatPearls: Valsalva Maneuver. NCBI Bookshelf. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK537248/
12. Talasz, H. et al. (2012). Proof of concept: Differential effects of Valsalva and straining maneuvers on the pelvic floor. European Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Reproductive Biology, 164(2), 227–233.
13. Talasz, H. et al. (2022). Breathing, (s)training and the pelvic floor—a basic concept. PMC. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222935/
14. Tsai, T. C., & Hodges, P. W. (2013). Effect of airway control by glottal structures on postural stability. Journal of Applied Physiology, 115(4), 582–592. https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/japplphysiol.01226.2012
15. Wallace, K. (2020). Valsalva and the vaginal vacuum. Pelvic Resources. https://kathewallace.com/articles/valsalva-and-the-vaginal-vacuum/
✅ Fact-Check of the Above
Here is a critical assessment of the major claims made above:
Claim: “The vocal cords rest in an open position like a ‘V’ during normal breathing.”
✅ Verified. This is standard, well-established anatomy, confirmed by multiple authoritative sources including Cleveland Clinic and Kenhub.
Claim: “The posterior cricoarytenoid is the only abductor of the true vocal cords.”
✅ Verified. This is a well-established anatomical fact, confirmed by StatPearls/NCBI.
Claim: “Open-glottis breathing generates less intra-abdominal pressure than closed-glottis (Valsalva) breathing.”
✅ Generally verified, with an important nuance. Greater lung volumes before the closing of the glottis have been shown to increase IAP resulting from the descending diaphragm acting on the relatively incompressible abdominal contents. Open-glottis breathing avoids the additional spike in IAP from a sealed airway, but inhalation itself still increases IAP even with an open glottis. The claim is directionally accurate but is a simplification.
Claim: “Open-glottis pushing reduces the risk of pelvic floor tearing in childbirth.”
⚠️ Partially supported, but overstated by some sources. The NICE evidence review clearly found that there was no evidence of an important difference between groups for nulliparous or mixed parity women, with or without an epidural, in terms of third/fourth degree tears. Claims of reduced tearing are not consistently borne out by the most rigorous systematic evidence, though some individual studies report benefits.
Claim: “One Egyptian study found that open-glottis users needed no supplemental oxygen compared to 74% in the closed-glottis group.”
⚠️ Plausible but requires caution. This finding is striking and comes from a single study of 150 Egyptian primiparous women. It has not been replicated in larger, multi-center trials. The finding is reported faithfully from its source but should not be generalized without further corroboration.
Claim: “For multiparous women without an epidural, open-glottis pushing reduced the duration of the active second stage.”
✅ Verified. This is directly supported by the NICE evidence review (NCBI Bookshelf, NBK596203), which synthesized multiple trials.
Claim: “The Valsalva maneuver causes the pelvic floor to elevate, while a straining maneuver causes the pelvic floor to descend.”
✅ Verified by Talasz et al. (2012) and confirmed by Baessler et al. (2017), both peer-reviewed studies. This is an important and often confused clinical distinction.
Claim: “ELTGOL is equally effective as other airway clearance techniques for sputum production in bronchiectasis.”
✅ Verified, per Herrera-Cortina et al. (2016) as cited by Bronchiectasis.com.au, a professionally maintained clinical resource. This finding is specific to short-term sputum clearance and may not generalize to all pulmonary outcomes.
Claim: “Closed-glottis pushing can restrict blood flow to the uterus and baby.”
✅ Supported, though mechanistically complex. The Valsalva maneuver transiently reduces cardiac output by compressing venous return, which is the established physiological explanation. Blood pressure rises at the onset of straining because the increased intrathoracic pressure is added to the pressure in the aorta. It then falls because the ITP compresses the veins, decreasing the venous return and cardiac output. This hemodynamic disruption is the plausible basis for reduced uteroplacental flow.
Overall verdict: The core physiology and anatomy described is well-supported by peer-reviewed literature. The strongest caveats apply to childbirth-related claims: benefits of open-glottis pushing (particularly for tearing and neonatal outcomes) are plausible and supported by some studies, but the highest-quality systematic reviews show the evidence is mixed or inconclusive for many outcomes, especially for first-time mothers and those with epidurals.
No comments:
Post a Comment