As conveyed by word of mouth Advincula sensei tells the story as a first hand witness:
“Tatsuo's feelings were hurt by some of the senior Masters from Naha who did not agree with his new style of karate. Once while sitting in the dojo after class several of us were sitting and drinking. Tatsuo liked to drink Awamori an Okinawan distilled alcohol made from certain type of long grain rice which comes from Southeast Asia. There were many bottles of awamori,pine juice, and beer of various sizes on the table. Others present were drinking beer or mixing the awamori with pine juice a pineapple juice. Tatsuo asked the students ‘Which is the best bottle?’ Those who were drinking beer stated the beer bottles,others picked the largest bottles,and some chose the smaller bottles. Shimabuku said ‘all the bottles were good. All of them served a purpose: to hold what they were intended to. There is no best bottle,’ he said. What Tatsuo was saying was each had a purpose and all were good. He was relating this to karate.” - Arcenio Advincula Sensei Isshinryu Isshinkai (https://tinyurl.com/ym4cp6b2)
Another way to view this is, “All Styles are Good. All of them serve a purpose: to provide what they are intended to. There is no best style of karate! There is only one”
It makes perfect sense because all the styles are based on fundamental principles. I see this as a fundamental philosophy of Tatsuo-san’s karate 🥋 and if you add in the goku-I as well as the dojo-kun his philosophy begins to emerge and as he intended, it puts it in our hands to guide us in our own development of our own philosophy.
p.s., the reason we really don’t have or know Tatsuo-san’s philosophy on Isshinryu is because the first-gen’s and others were pestering him to fill there own agendas about methodology and they failed to “listen.” Tatsuo-San instead when pestered simply went along with these pesky Americans to maintain both his personal harmony and his lucrative military contract to teach the military karate.
Blasphemous you say; how the f*^* do you know you say; where do you get off besmirching our master you say?
Well, I have done some pretty involved research of available facts, as word of mouth facts go, especially at one reliable first-gen data-based source, when you begin to put together bits and pieces the picture is created of “one more possibility” that, like all of his history and teachings, cannot be validated or verified except through questionable process of q&a with fallible humans with a considerable void of different cultures, beliefs, agendas and language barriers, etc.!
Read more here: https://tinyurl.com/arswjew
No comments:
Post a Comment