
Lundy Guyton Sensei, a forum member and Yon-dan in Isshinryu, provided me the following information during a forum discussion on "Most Overlooked Aspect of Training."
[Author Bruce D. Clayton Ph.D in his book "Shotokan's Secret" says that Chotoku Kyan's karate was a throw back to before this. and I quote "In particular, Tatsuo Shimabuku studied under Kyan during the 1930s when the master was in his 60s. At that time, Kyan had gone back to basics by teaching older versions of Okinawan kata instead of the forms modified at Shuri. These kata are preserved in Shimabuku's style, Isshin-Ryu. The Isshin-Ryu kata are in a time capsule showing karate before Shuri-te."]
I post it hear as information that has not been verified. I don't assume in today's books that things said or quoted are factual unless the book provides some source that is closer to actual historical data or his some verifiable and acceptable source for all Isshinryu'ists, etc. It is an interesting quote and of course as any Isshinryu practitioner would like to believe it. But, ....
I have asked a Isshinryu historian to see if he can provide more on this quote as to its believability. Petty Officer Andy Sloane is currently stationed for an extended tour on Okinawa and has a good relationship with those who practice and teach Isshinryu as well as other systems. He has access to the older generation who may have known and studied with Tatsuo Sensei.
Anyway, take it with a grain of salt and stay tuned for any further information on this particular tidbit of data :-)
No comments:
Post a Comment