In a recent article at the Kowakan Blog titled, "Paragons of Health: I Think Not," brings up some relevant points in the practice and teaching of martial systems (in this particular example Okinawan Karate). His post made me think, when is it prudent to stop the leadership role, one that requires health, fitness, knowledge and experience, etc.?
I will use myself as an example. First, as we age (I am closing in by months to my winter years, i.e. 60 years) things change in the body and mind that we may or may not have control over. I have meniere's which is an inner ear thing causing vertigo and my status is the problem remains lingering with bouts where I lose more balance and then gain it back with about 98% most times. Should I teach?
There can be many factors involving a sensei who reaches toward their winter years. There can be many factors that crop up suddenly that will affect a person health, fitness and well-being that could effect their teaching abilities. How you handle those and incorporate them into your training, practice and teaching matters - they matter a great deal.
Physical disciplines like martial systems require demonstration to supplement the whole teaching model. It means you must be able to demonstrate. It does not mean you have to keep up with younger, healthier and more fit practitioners but you must be able to demonstrate. You must lead by example and your health, fitness and demeanor to include how you walk, talk and the aura you project by the spirit and physical is important.
I liken sense to the military leadership I came to understand as a Marine. Your life depends on the what, how, who, when and other factors of those who would lead. The examples you set by the actions you take mean a lot, a lot. If a Marine goes fat, lazy and becomes unhealthy no matter the past credentials they lose a huge amount of credentials with those who have to do. This applies to all of life but no more so than in the military where your life depends on others of like minded military presence, etc.
If you are not going to maintain your health, fitness and mind/body for your age as appropriate and if you are not going to maintain a level of expertise and continual update and change to your knowledge and experiences then you should consider relinquishing the mantle of sensei.
I stopped teaching a few years back and now remain healthy, fit and knowledgable through personal practice and training. I keep researching and theorizing and working it out in my practice (as much as possible without a partner, etc.) to maintain a certain level of knowledge and expertise. I do realize that the lack of working it out with others, i.e. sensei, senpai and kohai, etc., limits my growth but I realize that as I enter the winter years and due to certain uncontrolled issues of mind and body I would not benefit practitioners on the dojo floor so I am kind of retired from teaching.
I am not overweight nor infirm to the point that I cannot do my martial arts but it may lack what I perceive is necessary to give a full and complete system of martial arts over to those who would follow. I relegated myself to an advisor in a academic form with emphasis that one must take all I provide to the dojo floor to work out with a sensei/senpai before melding it to their practice and training.
An important, a critical essence that is teaching and practicing is knowing when to adjust to the aging process and knowing when to step down as a sensei on the dojo floor. A very difficult thing to detect within yourself. Like many things, it takes hard work and a lot of self-reflection.
I agree with you that instructors need to maintain good insight into their ability to keep teaching. I respect instructors much more when I can see that they are still making the effort to stay fit and healthy and continue to train themselves. I hate to see an instructor who is clearly out of shape or out of date, especially if they are younger than me (I'm 51). It's amazing how many people in their forties seem to think its time to slow down and start moaning about their aches and pains. Wimps I say!
ReplyDeleteAnd another thing: At 60 you are not in your winter years, you have at least another 10 years before you're allowed to think that!
Winter years starting at age 60 is generally how the Chinese classics tend to explain it .... at 59.8 years with 60 just around the bend I feel pretty darn good and often am amazed how much healthier and fit I am compared to many barely in their thirties and forties.
ReplyDelete;-)
Chinese classics, by definition, are out of date when it comes to today's life expectancy. 60 is the new 40!
ReplyDeleteI agree and disagree. Asian's tend to live a longer life then most humans. Actually due to western influences life expectancy in Okinawa has actually decreased as well as both Chinese and Japanese.
ReplyDeleteOur food industry is very addictive, i.e. sugar, salt and fat, so actually, in my perceptions, the classics are actually speaking to a soon to be gone life expectancy, i.e. of 90 or 100 years or longer.
The only ones who will actually benefit from modern medicine as to longevity are the privileges and economically affluent ;-)
How's that for an answer ;-) hehehehehehe
Actually the average life expectancy in Okinawa 200 years ago was about 40 except among karate practitioners who were living to 70 or 80, that's how they realised that exercise and good life style choices were essential for health.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, it's immaterial; we're all generally living longer these days and so 60 is not the beginning of the winter years. If you still think it is you are in for a long hard winter!
Here's hoping you continue to enjoy a warm and sunny Autumn.....:-)